An End-Of-Season Tradition: Bruce Bronster, Chef Michael White, & 250 Pounds Of Heirloom Tomatoes

Chef Michael White & Bruce Bronster

Every summer’s end, Bruce Bronster, co-owner of Santi — the Midtown East Italian restaurant co-owned with Chef Michael White — turns his Sag Harbor home into a one-day tomato-processing operation.

Bruce and Chef Michael worked through 250 pounds of heirloom tomatoes, making separate sauces from yellow, orange, and red varieties. With an 80-quart pot and an electric grinder, they cooked, ground, and reduced the tomatoes for hours before preserving the sauce in Mason jars.

None of it is for sale. They brought some jars back to Santi and shared them with other chefs and friends. They shared the art of the process with us.

You recently turned your Sag Harbor home into an annual tomato-processing operation. How did this tradition originally begin, and what inspired you to bring it back?

Bruce: Chefs have always loved the rituals surrounding food — fishing, clamming, crabbing, picking, foraging, and preparing ingredients together. Tomato jarring is really an extension of that. It’s an age-old tradition, dating back to a time before refrigeration, when families preserved the bounty of summer to enjoy throughout the winter. There’s something wonderful about taking beautiful ingredients at their peak and preserving them for another season.

The tradition really comes from Michael’s wife, Giovanna, and her Italian heritage. She grew up with memories of her family preparing and preserving tomatoes together, and she and Michael have carried that tradition forward for years.

We’ve now made it our own annual gathering in Sag Harbor. It combines so many things we love: great food, family, friendship, and a little bit of organized chaos.

Santi celebrates Italian cuisine and its traditions. How does the philosophy behind preserving tomatoes at Bruce’s Sag Harbor home connect to the way you approach the menu at Santi?

Michael: At its heart, Italian cooking is about respecting ingredients, understanding seasonality, and preserving traditions. Tomato jarring is a perfect example. You’re taking tomatoes at the absolute height of their season and capturing those flavors to enjoy long after summer has ended.

That’s very much the philosophy behind Santi. We celebrate the traditions of Italian cooking while using the very best ingredients available to us. Clean, simple, and farm-fresh. It’s also about the experience of cooking together. In Italy, food preparation has always been a family activity, something that brings generations and friends together. For Giovanna, this is a tradition rooted in her childhood and her family’s Italian heritage. Being able to continue that tradition with our own family and friends makes it particularly meaningful.

Do you see this becoming a permanent annual tradition, and are there other seasonal food traditions you’d like to explore in the future?

Bruce: Absolutely. This was our fourth year, so I think we can officially call it a tradition. Traditions are incredibly important to us, particularly the old-world customs that bring families and friends together around food. We love holiday celebrations and the rituals that make different seasons special.

For example, I’ve been picking wild wineberries with my chef friends in a few secret spots around the Hamptons every July for more than 15 years. It’s something we look forward to every summer. Next on my list is truffle foraging in Umbria! I love the idea of heading into the woods with a dog and coming back with something extraordinary for dinner. Ultimately, these traditions are about much more than the food. They’re about the memories you create along the way.

Walk us through the actual process. From selecting the tomatoes to cooking and preserving them, what goes into creating the final jars?

Michael: Traditionally, Italian families use only plum tomatoes for preserving, but we’ve taken a slightly different approach. We’re using a combination of beautiful local heirloom and plum tomatoes, with a particular emphasis on yellow varieties, including Sungolds, which have an incredible natural sweetness.

This year we did two separate batches — one yellow and one red. We begin by selecting the ripest tomatoes and boiling them. We then clean and deseed them before transferring them into clean glass jars. The jars are sealed and returned to boiling water for a second round of heat processing. It’s a traditional method that has been passed down through generations.

The yellow tomatoes are particularly interesting because they produce something quite different from a traditional red tomato sauce. They’re delicate, naturally sweet, and have a beautiful golden color. The goal is to capture the extraordinary flavor of tomatoes at their summer peak.

This year, you processed an impressive 250 pounds of heirloom tomatoes. How did the operation evolve from last year’s batch, and what did you learn along the way?

Bruce: Last year was a much more hands-on operation. We were processing the tomatoes by hand and cooking everything in relatively small pots. It was wonderful, but it was also an enormous amount of work.

This year Michael decided we needed to professionalize the operation. He took charge of the equipment and ordered state-of-the-art cooking gear, including two enormous pots that each hold 80 gallons. We’ve essentially gone from a family kitchen operation to something resembling a small commercial tomato-processing facility. I’m not sure whether we’re preserving tomatoes or opening a cannery at this point.

Michael: The biggest difference this year is that we have equipment that allows us to work much more efficiently and consistently. When you’re dealing with hundreds of pounds of tomatoes, the logistics become important. You want to maintain the quality of the ingredients while making the process manageable.

But the essential idea hasn’t changed. It’s still about taking exceptional tomatoes at their peak and preserving them with care. And despite all the new equipment, it’s still a family affair. That’s really the most important part.

Can you tell us a bit about your partnership? How did the two of you first come together?

Bruce: Michael and I first met at Alto, at Table 24, sometime around 2008. We’ve known each other for nearly two decades, and over the years our relationship has evolved into a wonderful friendship that extends well beyond the restaurant business. I’ve represented Michael in legal matters, but more importantly, our families have spent years cooking, traveling, eating, and celebrating together.

Food has always been at the center of our friendship, so creating Santi together was a natural extension of that relationship. The tomato-jarring tradition is really just another chapter in a friendship built around food, family, and a shared appreciation for the good things in life.

What about Sag Harbor makes it the perfect setting for this kind of tradition?

Bruce: The Hamptons have an extraordinary agricultural history. For generations, this was farming country, known particularly for its potato fields. Today, that agricultural heritage continues through an incredible collection of small farms producing some of the best fruits and vegetables anywhere.

The heirloom tomatoes out here are spectacular. The variety, the colors, the flavors — it’s really remarkable. And Sag Harbor has a wonderful sense of community and history that makes these kinds of old-world traditions feel particularly appropriate. There’s something very satisfying about gathering friends and family in the kitchen, working with ingredients grown just a few miles away, and preserving a little bit of summer to enjoy in the middle of winter.

That’s what makes the tradition special.

Jessica Mackin-Cipro

Co-Publisher/Editor

Jessica Mackin-Cipro is an editor and lifestyle writer from the East End of Long Island. She was previously the Executive Editor of The Independent Newspaper and co-founded James Lane Post in 2020. She has won multiple NYPA and PCLI awards for journalism, design, and social media, including the Stuart C. Dorman Award for Editorial Excellence. In 2023, she was a recipient of the President's Volunteer Service Award at the United Nations 67th Annual Commission on the Status of Women. She aims to share the stories of inspirational people and places on the East End and beyond.

An East End Experience

2024 © James Lane Post®. All Rights Reserved.

Covering North Fork and Hamptons Events, Hamptons Arts, Hamptons Entertainment, Hamptons Dining, and Hamptons Real Estate. Hamptons Lifestyle Magazine with things to do in the Hamptons and the North Fork.