Real Estate Confab: The East End Dream. What Are Buyers Really Buying?

On the East End, buying a home is rarely just about ticking boxes. It’s the number of bedrooms, the ocean view, a prized zip code, or an architect’s pedigree. For plenty of people, it starts as an escape from the city’s heat and noise. For others, it’s about finding their place, finally feeling like they fit in, or signaling they’ve arrived. Sometimes, it’s about fulfilling a lifelong fantasy. Lately, though, there’s another layer: the vision of a different life, the one people dream up the minute the front door swings open.

We brought together some of the area’s top real estate agents and asked them to forget the paperwork for a minute. What are people actually buying out here? Is it walls, land, and a view — or is it something else entirely? Is it the promise of reinvention, a passport into the Hamptons’ private world, or that elusive feeling of belonging? Their answers go beyond dollar signs and property lines, getting to the complicated hopes, desires, and enduring magic that keep drawing people to the East End year after year.

Sheri Winter Parker, The Corcoran Group

Sheri Winter Parker. Courtesy of The Corcoran Group

I bought my house on the North Fork after a weekend getaway to Shelter Island. Driving through the North Fork on my way back to Manhattan, I felt the vibe and energy shift — and it spoke to me on another level. I felt relaxed, with a sense of inner peace that was definitely missing from my day-to-day life at the time.

I picked up some real estate magazines and thought, “One day…” Three weeks later, walking in from work at 11 PM on a Friday, I said to no one in particular, “I need to get a life!”

Don’t get me wrong — I absolutely loved my job. It just struck me that I wanted something more. I made appointments for the next day and bought one of the houses I’d asked to see. And just like that, I bought myself a lifestyle.

That’s what I find buyers are truly looking for when they’re buying a house out East. It’s not just a house — it’s a lifestyle, where each town has its own flavor. There are plenty of lifestyles to choose from, which makes it all even more fun!

Deborah Pirro, Sotheby’s International Realty/Daniel Gale Realty

Deborah Pirro. Courtesy of Sotheby’s International Realty/Daniel Gale Realty

Buying a home on the East End is an invitation to a lifestyle shaped by ocean beaches, charming villages, and time well spent, from morning walks along the shore to evenings entertaining friends at home. Each zip code offers its own vibe, appealing to different personalities: the understated elegance of Quogue, the welcoming energy of Westhampton Beach, Southampton’s classic sophistication, Bridgehampton’s blend of equestrian heritage and contemporary style, Sag Harbor’s maritime and artistic spirit, and Montauk’s laid-back surf culture.

Finding your home here is not only about a property, but about discovering a setting that feels like you, exploring where you are in life and who you want to become.

Barry McGovern, Hedgerow Exclusive

Barry McGovern. Courtesy of Hedgerow Exclusive Properties

People think they’re buying square footage, a pool, or a water view. What they’re really buying is time. Most of my buyers can live anywhere in the world, and they choose the East End because it gives them back the hours the city takes away: long dinners, kids on bikes, a morning on the bay before anyone checks a phone. The house is just the frame for that.

That’s why the best properties right now aren’t always the biggest. They’re the ones that make life easy from the first weekend: finished, close to the village, and private without feeling remote. Buyers will pay a real premium for a home they don’t have to fix, because the one thing they can’t buy more of is summers.

I moved here from Dublin in 2013 and fell for Sag Harbor the same way my clients do. It still feels like a real place, and that’s what people are paying for.

Mary Slattery, The Corcoran Group

Mary Slattery. Courtesy of The Corcoran Group

What a great question! People really buy on the East End for a variety of reasons. I do think that most, if not all, buy for the Hamptons lifestyle. It is why I bought my first home out East almost 30 years ago. In those days, I was a weekend, year-round, and summer person. Of course, the Hamptons were different then. Much more bucolic and laid-back. We did not even refer to the East End as “The Hamptons.” For me, it was an escape from the city hustle and bustle. The Hamptons as a community is much more like where I grew up on the North Shore of Chicago. I grew up in a little village with Lake Michigan for beaches and boating and very close proximity to downtown Chicago for city fun. The Hamptons felt like home to me then. And still does, which is why I moved here full-time 26 years ago. Over time, the Hamptons have become much more of an aspirational place for summer renters and buyers and very much a social scene in season. I feel like the Hamptons brought me back to my roots, and I try to convey that to all of my rental and sales clients.

Sebastian Mobo, SERHANT

Hamptons Real Estate
Sebastian Mobo. Courtesy of SERHANT

I think it’s probably a little bit of everything, but ultimately, it’s the lifestyle. Of course, people are buying a home, and there’s always an investment aspect to it. There’s also something about the Hamptons that people are drawn to — the beauty, the communities, the restaurants, the beaches, and even the social side of being here.

But I think what people are really looking for is a different pace of life. More time outdoors, more time with family and friends, entertaining at home, enjoying the beach, or simply having a little more room to breathe.

I’ve seen this firsthand working with clients this year, including a few from abroad who are looking for a second home on the East End. I think there’s something universally appealing about having a place where you can spend more time with family, slow down, and enjoy a different pace of life.

I’m also seeing how the Hamptons have evolved beyond just being a summer destination. For many people, it’s becoming a much bigger part of their lives, whether that’s spending more time here throughout the year or making it their primary home.

And I think that’s what makes owning a home here so special. It’s not just about the house itself, but the memories and experiences that come with it. Ultimately, people want a place where they can really enjoy life.

Susan Ryan, Compass

Susan Ryan. Courtesy of Compass

I think it’s a little bit of everything, but ultimately people are buying a place that fits the life they want to live. For some, it’s a full-time home where they can raise a family and become part of a wonderful community. For others, it’s a weekend escape, a place to slow down, relax, and spend time with the people they love. The East End offers such a special combination of natural beauty, community, and lifestyle. I think people are drawn here for different reasons, but at the end of the day, they’re looking for a place that feels like their own and makes them happy.

Ty Wenzel

Co-Publisher & Contributor

Ty Wenzel, a recent breast cancer survivor, started her career as a fashion coordinator for Bloomingdale’s followed by fashion editor for Cosmopolitan Magazine. She was also a writer for countless publications, including having published a memoir (St. Martin's Press) and written features for The New York Times. She is an award-winning writer and designer who covers lifestyle, real estate, architecture and interiors for James Lane Post. She previously worked as a writer and marketing director for The Independent. She has won multiple PCLI and NYPA awards for journalism, social media and design, including best website design and best magazine for James Lane Post, which she co-founded in 2020. Wenzel is also the founder of the Hamptons social media agency, TWM Luxury Solutions.

An East End Experience

2024 © James Lane Post®. All Rights Reserved.

Covering North Fork and Hamptons Events, Hamptons Arts, Hamptons Entertainment, Hamptons Dining, and Hamptons Real Estate. Hamptons Lifestyle Magazine with things to do in the Hamptons and the North Fork.